Fifty-five thousand, one hundred fifty-two. That’s how many bachelor’s and master’s degrees in accounting were awarded in the 2023–2024 academic year, a 6.6% drop from the year before, according to data the Journal of Accountancy reported from AICPA tracking. For a small firm competing against national players for the same shrinking pool of candidates, that number matters.

The picture isn’t uniformly bleak. Accounting program enrollment climbed 12.4% in spring 2025 to 266,506 students, the highest level since 2020. New CPA Exam candidates bounced back too: 16,448 entered the pipeline in the first half of 2025, after a dip to 28,082 for all of 2024 from 42,626 in 2023. Roughly 75% of public accounting firms expected to hire at least as many new graduates in 2025 as they did in 2024, per the same Journal of Accountancy analysis.

A Tighter Market, A Different Kind of Competition

Small firms and solo practitioners aren’t chasing the same candidates as the Big Four, and that’s the point. A recruiting budget measured in hundreds of dollars, not tens of thousands, forces a different strategy: relationships over ad spend, specificity over scale.

State CPA society job boards remain one of the lower-cost channels available, often priced well below national job platforms and reaching candidates already filtered for licensure interest. University accounting departments, particularly at regional schools less likely to see recruiters from national firms, are another channel small practices can access directly through faculty relationships and guest lecture invitations.

Recruiting Channels That Don’t Require a Recruiting Budget

– Employee referral programs: a modest bonus tied to a successful 90-day retention costs a fraction of an agency placement fee.

– Local chapter events through state CPA societies, where candidates and career-changers actively network.

– LinkedIn posts written by the firm’s own staff about client work, culture, or a specific open role, rather than paid job ads.

– Career changers and non-traditional candidates: bookkeepers pursuing licensure, former auditors returning after time away, military veterans with financial backgrounds.

– Part-time, fractional, or remote arrangements that widen the geographic pool beyond commuting distance.

Writing a Posting That Attracts the Right Candidate

A vague posting draws vague applicants. Specificity does more work than most small firms give it credit for: the actual client mix, the technology stack in daily use, the realistic path to partnership or ownership, and a salary range instead of “competitive compensation.” Candidates screening multiple postings a week skip past the ones that read like a template.

Interview design matters just as much. A single structured conversation covering technical background, client-facing skills, and cultural fit, followed by a short case-based exercise, moves faster than the multi-round gauntlet larger firms use and doesn’t lose the candidate to a competing offer in the meantime.

What Small Practices Get Wrong

The same mistakes recur across firms of this size. Job postings stay generic because nobody wants to spend the time customizing them. The interview process stretches across three or four weeks because scheduling keeps slipping, and strong candidates accept elsewhere while the firm deliberates. Growth path and compensation trajectory go unmentioned until an offer is already on the table, by which point the candidate has already formed an impression.

Culture fit assessment gets skipped entirely in some small-firm processes, treated as a luxury reserved for firms with HR departments. It isn’t. A five-minute conversation about how the candidate handles a tight deadline or a difficult client interaction surfaces more than a resume ever will.

Onboarding: The Step Budget-Conscious Firms Skip

Hiring is only half the equation. A new hire’s first 90 days shape whether the recruiting investment pays off or the firm is back to square one. Structured onboarding, meaning a documented first-week plan, an assigned mentor, and scheduled check-ins at 30, 60, and 90 days, doesn’t require software or a formal HR function. It requires a checklist and follow-through.

Retention Is Part of the Hiring Calculus

A hire that leaves within a year erases most of what a low-cost recruiting process saved. Lost productivity during the search, ramp-up time for a replacement, and disruption to client relationships all sit downstream of the hiring decision itself, even though they rarely show up in a hiring budget line. Firms that treat the first year as part of the hiring process, not a separate retention problem, tend to see fewer repeat searches.

That framing changes how a small firm evaluates a candidate at the offer stage. Fit and growth trajectory matter as much as technical skill, because a technically strong hire who leaves in eight months costs more than a slightly less polished hire who stays.

Remote and Fractional Arrangements Widen the Pool

Geography used to cap a small firm’s candidate pool at commuting distance. Remote and hybrid arrangements remove that constraint, and fractional or part-time roles open the door to experienced professionals who left full-time practice but would take on defined client work. A semi-retired CPA willing to handle a specific client segment ten hours a week is a candidate most small firms never consider because the posting assumes full-time from the start.

Surgent’s Today’s Entrepreneur: Hiring and Recruiting With a Limited Budget (EHR2), a live webinar taught by Dave Peters on Oct. 2, covers low-cost recruiting channels, job posting and interview design, and onboarding structure for firms operating without a dedicated HR function.